+1 Since these lines are greyed out in a PR-review it is not possible to comment on them. . 1314 . I'm not really sure how to do this. For example, this is one for an app that I worked on — FoodbLog. Cette configuration facilite aussi le fait d’avoir plusieurs collaborateurs travaillant sur le même projet. Star 0 Fork 0; Star Code Revisions 2. Add a comment | 19 Answers Active Oldest Votes. Well, you’ll be glad to know that you can now remove them using the web-based interface too! This is how it is done: $ vim myfile.rb -s format.vim If it is your first time opening a file in GitHub Desktop from your browser, you might be asked to grant permission to your computer to open the file in GitHub Desktop. 6,003 4 4 gold badges 40 40 silver badges 58 58 bronze badges. Once downloaded, you need to unzip the folder. Each of these types of comments goes through a different portion of the GitHub Enterprise Server API. Note that some features of GitHub Flavored Markdown are only available in the descriptions and comments of Issues and Pull Requests. Simply view any file in your repository, click the delete button at the top, and commit the removal just like any other web-based edit. I realise this isn't what people were asking for but it might work in a pinch. I am surprised that this doesn't work in Github. 6. If you've never used Git or GitHub before, you need to understand one of the most important tasks you'll use with the service: How to push a new project to a remote repository. `WorkshopId` should be `ulong` not `long`? Pourquoi ? Some of their notes may be about project-level design choices, others may be file-level thoughts, and still others may be line-by-line nits. And if you want something other than commit comments, see also: #211, +1 -- would love a way to comment in a PR on code not changed in the commits associated with that PR. Marking student work, I want to be able to leave comments all through any given file on the commit closest to the due time (not just on the lines that changed, because often it's just a merge and nothing changed). IMO, this is not just a feature request but a bug (missing basic functionality). 5. https://via.hypothes.is/https://gist.github.com/caugner/589cac8dbb07b26b34ff. It is used by version control systems to store multiple versions of files. Manu Manu. As far as I can tell, there has been no progress in GitHub in this area. (e.g. Never got a response. There … In fact, the whole purpose of Github is to provide a history of the file(s), so the purpose is not really served if one just downloads the most recent snapshot. (I hope my learning experience helps other developers who bump into the same issue). You do not need to use a remote to use git, but it will make sharing your code with … But anyhow, that depends on you own will. A good commented PR has to be able to refer to those. This is an obvious issue in my company when doing a code-review of a pull-request. Now, to send your files to GitHub, enter: 1 git push origin master. or comment on lines of code directly: This is what I was looking for, at least. 56 Copy link aheninger commented Jan 22, 2019 +1 Trying to review a PR that is cleaning up a class of problem in a file, and it missed one occurrence. From within the Secure Shell app, I … Someone has also created browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox to play tours in GitHub: https://github.com/doctolib/code-tours-github. Provide a means to flag/tag issues in code, https://via.hypothes.is/https://gist.github.com/caugner/589cac8dbb07b26b34ff. Task Lists are also available in Gist comments and in Gist Markdown files. or use the community, where also official GitHub employees are active. Example: 6. The .github/workflows directory in your repository is searched for workflow files at the associated commit SHA or Git ref. to your repo. Would be nice to be able to comment on a line and have github work out which commit it relates to automagically. Vim has some pretty nice standarts on what indention etc. Especially in a refactoring PR, there is no accurate way of pointing out to someone that they missed something. Check your repo on GitHub’s website and refresh the browser. @Exr0n That feature's existed for years. When I tried to upload this video to my GitHub repo, the push commit was rejected, because the file was larger than 50 MB. ), https://astrofrog.github.io/blog/2013/04/10/how-to-conduct-a-full-code-review-on-github/, Allow commenting on collapsed lines in PR, Use sample input instead of type as example, Remove flake8 W503 from docs as it is ignored by default, config: small refactoring and unit tests for types, [SPARK-32916][SHUFFLE][test-maven][test-hadoop2.7] Ensure the number of chunks in meta file and index file are equal, expand alert to include p and ul in message div, add rules for vertic…, https://github.community/t/feature-request-review-comment-on-whole-file/135108, https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=vsls-contrib.codetour, https://github.com/doctolib/code-tours-github. Ever tried to upload a large file to GitHub? So how do we push large files like audios, videos, datasets, and graphics to GitHub? Stack Exchange Network . Developers, engineers and designers all over the world are using GitHub to collaborate and share code with others. Some background: I think it’s a good practice to write descriptive README files for GitHub repos. Use a two-finger swipe to select multiple lines of code without a long press. You signed in with another tab or window. * Format SQL files on save. Octomments - using GitHub as a comment plugin / 87% of my readers are using Chrome on desktop. I found this related post on the GitHub support forum: https://github.community/t/feature-request-review-comment-on-whole-file/135108. Click the Upload Files files button and begin uploading files. But I just can't find the download button. Add the file to your repo. I would like to be able to comment on this, and for the PR author, the most useful place for me to leave the comment is next to the (as-yet-unchanged) code. GitHub Gist: instantly share code, notes, and snippets. Follow the few steps and successfully upload file or project on github using command line. I guess the underlying problem is that a PR-review is modeled as a review of a diff, instead of a review of the repository state at a certain commit. I want ... particular file from that repository. I only need one particular file from a project published on GitHub so it makes little sense to download the whole project. Click the blue Clone button in GitHub Desktop. I want to ask a colleague to take a look and give general feedback. This post explains how to do it manually: I've just encountered this issue. In my mental model, the comment relates to this PR, not to an old commit that made the code how it is. If someone could figure out how to make that work for all files, it would solve this problem. Si vous voulez collaborer sur n’importe quoi, vous devriez l’essayer. See the line context that a comment relates to, and view comments in a more readable UI on Files Changed. ), developers on all system can … How to Use WordPress and GitHub – Live Environment . That is, when we're reviewing PRs and need to add line notes or suggestions outside the context of the current patch. Nous sommes en 2013 et pas moyen d’y échapper : vous devrez apprendre comment utiliser GitHub. There's no way to point out the problem where it occurs. Sign in The way GitLab does this is very functional and seammless because it does not require hunting down the commit where code you want to comment was changed. Invitation AR whole file. You do not need GitHub to use git, but you cannot use GitHub without using git. Also, here’s the link to my favorite Atlassian tutorial on Git workflows for those who just shifted from individual to group projects. This is a fundamental flaw in GitHubs design of a review since you can not guarantee that changes in a diff only affect the lines in the diff itself. +1 -- Someone creates a PR to show me how they have changed the code to achieve a particular purpose. Reload the page of your repo on GitHub and you should see your committed files. Note that “repository” can be thought of as “folder” or “project”. +1 -- would love a way to comment _in a PR_ on code not changed in the commits associated with that PR. (Other than to create a branch, delete all contents of that branch, then make a PR from the actual repo contents against that blank branch. sometimes new code has rendered old docstrings obsolete and I want to mention this in a comment. Add a comment | 0. Last active May 13, 2019. However I just recently found that this blog has 56 (out of 100) points on Google's pagespeed test. And remember, everything comes with practice!! This means that I have the luxury to care less about performance. There has been some discussion about adding it to the GitHub UI: microsoft/codetour#10. I even timed it. Ayant … This video gives an easy approach to upload file/files on github without using git commands. Github is a source code repository that is stored on a server so that you can collaborate with your team. I have never had an issue in other Peer Review platforms. TPM @Microsoft / Creator of @Neverlate_App / Speaker @SignalConf / WWDC Scholarship 2016 / Formerly iOS @LinkedIn, @Vimeo, @C4QNYC, @iOSoho & Women in iOS Lead, git lfs track "*.psd" // for photoshop files, Can’t push to github (pre-receive hook declined), Issues with pushing large files through GIT, Quickly share ML WebApps from Google Colab using ngrok for free, A simple guide for Git cherry picking in TortoiseGit , Image-to-Recipe Translation with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks, Why Your Lazy Vars Aren’t Creating Strong Reference Cycles in iOS, 5 Git tricks every developer should know about, Better Code, Faster: ZenHub Helps the Best Software Teams Stay Focused, Follow directions in your push commit error and go to. https://astrofrog.github.io/blog/2013/04/10/how-to-conduct-a-full-code-review-on-github/. The report says that my Disqus comments are blocking the main thread for ~900ms. When reading someone's code I need to ask an author why he/she code that way, not another or ask for clarfication of piece of code for better understanding or suggest an alternative solution for consideration without making pull request. I also add video demos to show how my apps work. Trying to review a PR that is cleaning up a class of problem in a file, and it missed one occurrence. I certainly did. 5. Please consider support similar: https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/merge_requests/work_in_progress_merge_requests.html. Embed. @molysgaard Exactly this! And just like that, … This will begin the download of the repo to your computer. For example, this is one for an app that I worked on — FoodbLog. Here’s the tricky part: you probably already added and removed your large file a couple of times and tried to push to GitHub. sometimes new code has rendered old docstrings obsolete and I want to mention this in a comment. The most frustrating thing was that: 1) because the file was so big, and 2) because I didn’t know what I was doing, every push commit I was trying to make took soooooo long! Then add, commit, and push as usual. What @davidstanke said. That's not good. I’m going to include the search keywords that I used to research this problem, which may be helpful for people with the same issue: github pre-receive hook declined, github squash commits, git push large files, git outside repository. Learn how to run slow RSpec files on GitHub Actions with parallel jobs by doing an auto split of the spec file by test examples to get a faster CI build time. Say I have a repo that I've been working on for a while: lots of commits, lots of PRs (or maybe even no PRs, if I'm the sole author). To navigate down into a folder, just type the … If someone does this, can they post the reply/link here thanks. Resources: Git Large File Storage (LFS), Can’t push to github (pre-receive hook declined), Issues with pushing large files through GIT, GitHub Help: Working with large files (read this if you added and removed your large file from your repo multiple times), squashing commits with rebase, How to rebase a pull request. I also add video demos to show how my apps work. Features: * Format selected text or a whole file via keyboard shortcut or command. Create New Repository Glad they finally added it :). If folks know of other ones, could you add them here for reference? It can make sub-folder/sub-directory of github repository as zip and download it. First we will create a new repository on github and after we will fill the repository name and description. Check out the FoodbLog app on GitHub: github.com/ayunav/FoodbLog. The diff in a PR might require changes to lines that are not changed in the PR. There are many other alternatives to GitHub, such as GitLab, BitBucket, and “host-your-own” solutions such as gogs and gittea. I guess I could make an issue for each comment that references the line, but that means a lot of back and forth. Set up Git LFS tracking for the type of files you want to add to your repo. The latest thinking is that GitHub CodeSpaces will be "the natural mechanism for enabling developers to replay a tour from GitHub." Moving files to new locations. You’ll notice that editing a file now lets you enter a new name for your file. Why should it not be possible to comment on the call site with the old function name, where the problem actually is located? It doesn't matter how the code got to the state it's in; I'm asking for review of current state... the entire current state. You can drag one or more files from the desktop and then click Commit Changes to publish the files on the web. It happens often that the change is affecting the lines that are not part of this commit. Renaming a file. However, there is quite a steep learning curve to using GitHub. Github is a source … Instructions. should look like, so it might make sense to run those from the command line on files without haveing to launch vim by hand. This video will show you how to upload folders and files to github repositories.Like & Subscribe itzzmeakhi / invitation.html. Your file should be uploaded, despite the error message. A PR that removes the final use of a module, will cause problems up outside of the lines changed in the PR. In my case, my WordPress site is hosted on a Cloudways managed server. Now, your/my commits still have that large file data tracked locally that hasn’t been pushed. Github is free to use and extremely popular! I manage reproducing this on your online demo : I can't tell why, sometimes it … Hi Team, I have one repository in Github. If you’re confused which pattern to follow, I highly recommend the Atlassian’s tutorial above. It would be nice to know that someone in GitHub is aware of this issue and the amount of upvotes it has here. I thought this matched the description of the original comment for this issue: "allow commenting on any code in repository". How to do that? Does anyone know where were should post to have official answer? git log and git reset commands will help get back to that commit. Follow answered Dec 10 '18 at 15:35. (e.g. GitHub introduced their own CI server solution called GitHub Actions.You will learn how to set up your Ruby on Rails application on GitHub Actions with the YAML config file. You can also move files to entirely new locations using just the filename field. @muescha I have contacted them multiple times pointing to this repo. It would be nice to be able to point out, in context, where someone missed something in a documentation update. I think there is some code, unchanged in their PR, that should be changed to achieve the purpose of this PR. I agree this would be really useful, and we should be able to make suggestions too. So I need to comment any line of the file, not only near the changes. Even though Git originated on Linux (did you know that it was created by Linus Torvalds, the same guy who created Linux? I think of this in the context of an audit. LFS will now start tracking it and thus allow the push commit. Example: Note: after the data is finished uploading, you might see the same error (the file is too large) in your terminal. Which seems rather awkward.). bash. Using GitHub requires more than just committing a README file, but these basics should give you a good grasp on how to interact with the git app and the service. Already on GitHub? For any Pull Request, GitHub Enterprise Server provides three kinds of comment views: comments on the Pull Request as a whole, comments on a specific line within the Pull Request, and comments on a specific commit within the Pull Request. Have a question about this project? • Introducing a redesigned comment experience for pull request comments! Still no update on this from GitHub. how can we tag them here? Avoir à la fois un dépôt local et un dépôt à distance (en ligne), c’est tout bonnement le meilleur des deux mondes. I'm not aware of one. And it’s done, we can read and write a JSON file on GitHub with a React application also hosted on GitHub. @jasonkhadka-kd this is not a official github repo. I need to make comments to the code that I think was intended to be changed, but actually wasn't changed. If you go to any commit, you can scroll to the bottom to add a comment: i have done some of this kind of comments in commits, but never get an answer - i am not sure if they really delivered to the code owner. Welcome to 2021, dear readers. I think what we really want is the ability to start a review attached to an entire file at a given commit, and have it listed/linked among issues. Would be nice to hear official comment on this 🤔. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their … Once GitHub has become a part of your working routine, you will wonder how you managed without it. When you have a local environment and want to push WordPress files to GitHub repository. (If only they had a convenient platform where they could host their own bug tracker...). The workflow files must be present in that commit SHA or Git ref to be considered. To get around this, I used the scp command to copy the id_rsa.pub file to a remote server and then used the Secure Shell app to log in to that machine. Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue. These include @mentions as well as references to SHA-1 hashes, Issues, and Pull Requests. If you go to any commit, you can scroll to the bottom to add a comment: So I need to comment any line of the file, not only near the changes. As you can see, downloading files and whole projects from Github is actually quite easy. Not that you need more justification, but: In Go and some other languages, it is an error to import a module and not use it. Ok, I've finally read the description to this repo. Parce que c’est un réseau social qui change drastiquement notre façon de travailler. There's no way to point out the problem … The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: All code has a commit associated with it, and commits allow commenting (on both the commit, and each line within the commit). It doesn't make sense to always force people into making pull requests just so to get comments on code. If you are using GitHub Desktop UI, go to File ... > Enter your name (e.g. Improve this answer. There's a Visual Studio Code extension that would facilitate this process: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=vsls-contrib.codetour. There are many repositories that can be configured on a local machine for a single . Anybody found a way to do so? Starting today, you can move and rename files within your repositories on GitHub. +1 Though, I could not find any official public bug repository for GitHub cloud. 1ère Partie pour apprendre à démarrer sur GitHub. to your account. Allow commenting on non-pull-request code. GitHub est plus qu’un simple outil de programmation. Github will accept any file as long as the size is within the 25 MB limit. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails. It's not anything official. Leave suggestions for multiple lines, or comment on a whole function at once. Reindent and retab any file with vim from the shell. In just a couple of minutes, you can have an entire project downloaded onto your computer, or even forked to your own Github account. There fore it would useful communication in the context of the code line, so please, allow commenting on any code in repository. Deleting files on GitHub Coby Chapple You know all those files you’ve been creating, editing, moving, and renaming? privacy statement. For example, if the event occurred on a particular repository branch, then the workflow files must be present in the repository on that branch. Some background: I think it’s a good practice to write descriptive README files for GitHub repos. What would you like to do? This post is to help you save some valuable time. Log into GitHub and create a … Here’s what I did. @dgw what feature did you have in mind? Chacun de vous peut travailler seul sur son propre ordinateur, mais téléverser ou « push »er vo… Step 1: Create Repository on GitHub. Sometimes you want to allow people to more freely push code (ad-hoc/unimportant work). Hello, Sometimes when I have only one diff in a file, the whole file is marked as diff. FIRST add git lfs track, THEN add a large file (like audio, etc.) I’m going to assume that you have a WordPress site on your live server. I have multiple files on that repository. It helped me to become a better developer and a better team contributor. It's now been 6 years and 3 months. Inform the password of the SSH key if it asks. Embed Embed this gist in your … All of these are referred to in git-speak as “remotes”, and all are completely optional. My case, my WordPress site on your Live server will now tracking... ’ avoir plusieurs collaborateurs travaillant sur le même projet so that you can drag one or more files from shell! With others class of problem in a more readable UI on files changed all can! That exists in the commits associated with that PR of GitHub repository a good commented PR has to be to... For a single repositories that can be configured on a line and have GitHub work out which it. Is located tracker... ) someone creates a PR to show how my apps work upvotes. Context that a comment an example using Hypothesis to `` inject '' comments which! Machine for a single leave suggestions for multiple lines, or comment on a whole.... Through a different portion of the original comment for this issue and its... Someone does this, can they post the reply/link here thanks new name for your file has. Save some valuable time … add a comment who created Linux thinking is that GitHub CodeSpaces be! Is within the 25 MB limit make comments to the GitHub UI: microsoft/codetour # 10 actually is located what. Code repository that is cleaning up a class of problem in a GitHub PR for enabling developers to a! Some code, notes, and all are completely optional so how do we push large files like,... Is that GitHub CodeSpaces will be `` the natural mechanism for enabling developers to replay a tour from GitHub ''! That means a lot of back and forth account to open an for... Published on GitHub ’ s tutorial above collaborer sur n ’ importe,! Diff in a documentation update and the community have the luxury to care less about performance is GitHub! Other alternatives to GitHub repository as zip and download it qui change drastiquement notre façon de travailler devrez! And thus allow the push commit rendered old docstrings obsolete and I want to allow people to more push... Large file ( like audio, etc. of ability to do this add a comment | 19 Active... A class of problem in a pinch to store multiple versions of files … Invitation whole... Local machine for a single is quite a steep learning curve to using GitHub. for multiple of... Tours in GitHub in this area that are not changed in the commits associated that. A free GitHub account to open an issue and the amount of upvotes it has here request.... Star 0 Fork 0 ; star code Revisions 2 any code in repository own tracker. Or Git ref to be able to refer to those basic functionality.! Add line-by-line comments is to go through a different portion of the repo to your computer github comment on whole file is hosted a... Move and rename files within your repositories on GitHub using command line multiple versions of files you want mention... A central file storage location intended to be considered n't find the download of the original comment for this and... And give general feedback have always been frustrated by the lack of ability to do this GitHub repos moyen ’..., this is an obvious issue in my case, my WordPress site is hosted on server. Code not changed in the code github comment on whole file it is used by version control to... Vim from the shell be ` ulong ` not ` long ` the lines changed in context... Intended to be changed to achieve the purpose of this in the context of an audit datasets! • Introducing a redesigned comment experience for pull request may close this issue guy who created Linux plusieurs. You add them here for reference thought this matched the description to this repo leave suggestions multiple...: //gist.github.com/caugner/589cac8dbb07b26b34ff I hope my learning experience helps other developers who bump into the same issue ) pagespeed. Exr0N Most of us ( I think was intended to be able github comment on whole file. The change is affecting the lines changed in the docs WordPress site on Live. Ca n't find the download of the file, not to an old commit made..., so please, allow commenting on any code in repository with vim from the shell the... A file now lets you enter a new name for your file should be to. What indention etc. replay a tour from GitHub. final use of module... To more freely push code ( ad-hoc/unimportant work ) up outside of the,... Ar whole file via keyboard shortcut or command file-level thoughts, and graphics to GitHub their may. To someone that they missed something in a PR-review it is used by version control to... To follow, I guess I could not find any official public repository! Agree this would be nice to be able to refer to those just recently found that does! Le même projet in their PR, not only near the changes could! Markdown files referred to in git-speak as “ remotes ”, you ’ ll notice that editing a now. This PR can now remove them using the web-based interface too file tracked. Its maintainers and the community app that I worked on — FoodbLog could find. Function at once is not possible to comment on them file on GitHub: https: //github.com/doctolib/code-tours-github removes. Aussi le fait d ’ avoir plusieurs collaborateurs travaillant sur le même projet flag/tag Issues in code unchanged! The diff in a PR that is, when we 're reviewing PRs and need to add to your on... Whole file via keyboard shortcut or command your name ( e.g the associated... About adding it to the code line, but actually was n't changed to help you save valuable. They could host their own bug tracker... ) managed without it for a free GitHub account to an! And Firefox to play tours in GitHub: https: //astrofrog.github.io/blog/2013/04/10/how-to-conduct-a-full-code-review-on-github/ comment | Answers. Show how my apps work hasn ’ t been pushed allow the push commit changed, that... Renaming a function, but actually was n't changed close this issue and amount. Become a better developer and a better team contributor own bug tracker... ) will learn how to upload... And view comments in a comment plugin / 87 % of my readers are using GitHub. the. Diff in a GitHub PR does n't work in GitHub is a source … it can sub-folder/sub-directory. But that means a lot of back and forth Gist comments and in Gist and... A repository is a source code repository that is stored on a Cloudways server. It helped me to become a part of your working routine, you can also move files GitHub! One or more files from the desktop and then Click commit changes to github comment on whole file the files on the site. In mind refactoring PR, that depends on you own will of GitHub repository comment utiliser GitHub. would!, videos, datasets, and pull Requests still others may be file-level thoughts, and view comments in refactoring! To care less about performance who created Linux contacted them multiple times pointing to this repo comments is to through. Can collaborate with your team the changes to write descriptive README files for GitHub repos comment for... Like audio, etc. +1 Trying to review a PR might require changes to publish the on... Else this field can do few steps and successfully upload file or project on using! Agree this would be nice to hear official comment on this 🤔 you! So I need to add line-by-line comments is to help you save some valuable time a convenient where... Not be possible to comment any line of the file, not only near the.! Be really useful, and snippets on GitHub ’ s a good practice write! Situations like the one I described here comments and in Gist comments and in Gist Markdown.... Goes through a different portion of the lines that are not changed in the world are using Chrome desktop. Github UI: microsoft/codetour # 10 need one particular file from a project called ReviewNB that supports feature. Sha or Git ref to be able to comment on this 🤔 s tutorial above Gist Markdown files to! Collaborate with your team will help get back to that commit with vim from shell... Add a comment | 19 Answers Active Oldest Votes to rename all usages of it ) points Google... That should be able to refer to those for the type of files you want to this. Github CodeSpaces will be `` the natural mechanism for enabling developers to replay tour! Push as usual SHA-1 hashes, Issues, and push as usual mental model, same! You enter a new repository when you have a local environment and want to push WordPress files to,! Only need one particular file from a project published on GitHub with a React application also hosted on a file. Communication in the PR about adding it to the GitHub Enterprise server API how my apps work with! ) points on Google 's pagespeed test the.github/workflows directory in your is! Gitlab, BitBucket, and all are completely optional of these are referred to in git-speak as “ ”... Agree this would be nice to be able github comment on whole file make that work for files. Pull request workflow or a whole file file now lets you enter a repository. Official answer ’ y échapper: vous devrez apprendre comment utiliser GitHub. a long press the commit... Pointing to this repo its maintainers and the community, where the where! Pr_ on code @ mentions as well as references to SHA-1 hashes, Issues, and still may... A means to flag/tag Issues in code, notes, and all are completely optional lets. Example using Hypothesis to `` inject '' comments in their PR, that should be to...